Now Viewing: [Tagging] Gardeners Guild: Discuss Tagging Here!
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.
The kidnapped tag has 297 images and the kidnapping tag has 176. There's a wiki entry for kidnapping, so I think it's the correct one, so should all those images with kidnapped be changed to kidnapping? There's three pages of results for kidnapping -kidnapped, so there's a fair bit that aren't tagged with both.
pugsaremydrugs
- Group: Unofficial Gardener's Guild - Total Posts: 980
laura.loli said: The kidnapped tag has 297 images and the kidnapping tag has 176. There's a wiki entry for kidnapping, so I think it's the correct one, so should all those images with kidnapped be changed to kidnapping? There's three pages of results for kidnapping -kidnapped, so there's a fair bit that aren't tagged with both.
Danbooru only has a wiki page for kidnapping, just to expedite some of the process.
I can see tag '2girls' on this picture: gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1126078 I think it is for Roll and Roll Caskett. But I can see also 2 other girls of significantly smaller size: Sera and Yuna. Shouldn't they also be taken in account (then '4girls' should be instead of '2girls')?
schwarz-wohlf said: I can see tag '2girls' on this picture: gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1126078 I think it is for Roll and Roll Caskett. But I can see also 2 other girls of significantly smaller size: Sera and Yuna. Shouldn't they also be taken in account (then '4girls' should be instead of '2girls')?
Konbun doesn't have a gender so I'd say 5girls.
audreyani
- Group: Unofficial Gardener's Guild - Total Posts: 96
Hey. I asked this before a few months ago, but could I be given an exception for the tag editing delay? I wasn't active on the site for a while, but I've been editing more the past few days. Let me know, thanks.
pugsaremydrugs
- Group: Unofficial Gardener's Guild - Total Posts: 980
pugsaremydrugs said: Are tags like "no_panties" gender neutral or do they only work for female characters
no_briefs is a tag with a Danbo wiki but Danbo isn't using it, we are. no_panties says character not specifying male or female. Unless we make a change I don't think it matters.
Since we don't like having two tags for the same thing we might make a change. Maybe kill no_briefs using male search tags instead. We can also change all solo males to no_briefs or use no_panties for only trap/crossdressing males.
It seems really subjective. The wiki for it references the Von Luschan scale and states that 27-36 can qualify. I believe that only 33-36 should be considered however. Furthermore who even uses the Von Luschan scale anyway? The Wikipedia entry itself claims it is outdated.
My point is a fair amount of images seem improperly tagged with it. I can't really blame the wiki entry due to the ambiguity of the tag itself. Not to mention I am unsure of how many others use the wiki entries anyway.