fuck it
I'm sorry for adding up yet another post to this bs but this is getting really annoying

cmon man where tf did I say or Imply anything like that

Look, I simply said that in my opinion, post #280353 is yuri. The girl is bending over another girl's ass, she is grabbing it with her two hands, and is undressing her. I wouldn't call that "incidental contact". So yes, I will say it again: I think it is yuri.(and I'm talking about the tag and nothing else)
Now it is a grey area, and I can understand if mods said it should not be tagged yuri. (And quite frankly at the end of the day I don't care)
But I'm really sorry but I don't even understand why you're shitting on me like that, Idk why you're involving fucking Wikipedia or talking about the first line of the wiki (while I quoted the whole thing???), like I'm sorry I really don't get it

She is just presenting the other girl. I went to check the manga nhentai.net/g/61827/, (Yeah, I know, tag what you see.), I wanted to see why my brain tells me that is not yuri, why the lack of yuri energy. And I got my answer, the manga is not yuri, that girl is just presenting the other girl.

Sexual, yes, lesbian, no.

I don't think tags need to match the definition of the words they use 1:1. That is, just because yuri means lesbian doesn't mean that a pic needs to follow an strict definition of lesbian in order to get the yuri tag. Obviously if there's a dude or a dick in the middle it should be tagged with bisexual_female instead of yuri, but there's nothing wrong with tagging yuri on pics of girls touching each other sexually even if they're not into each other.
This is a porn-oriented site, so this level of leniency should be allowed, it makes these pics easier to search rather than relying on subjective terms like "lesbian energy".

If they are not going to respect what Yuri means they should rename the tag to female_on_female or something.

Yes, I know I shouldn't had used that term, but, I needed something to describe when girls are actually on each other. It is something that you can notice in the picture.

The problem with this way of thinking is that it prioritises strict, literal definitions over making the tags useful for users. The word yuri is used for the tag because it's catchy and easily understandable by those who are expected to use the site. "female_on_female" is not catchy and bound to open a can of worms for other tags.

If I search for yuri+ass_grab, then I expect post #280353 to be in that search result. Otherwise I would have to search for something like ass_grab+multiple_girls-futanari-hetero-1boy-*_boys (and hetero and boy tags are commonly not tagged at all). It is simply more useful to tag all pictures with girls interacting sexually with each other as yuri to make them easily searchable.

As for your idea of pictures with girls "into each other", that could be solved by using a tag like couple, which implies emotional intimacy.
Conversely, the cases where I think girls "being into each other" should be taken into account is when tagging bisexual_female. In this point, I disagree with BRANLIX2000 about those pics being tagged bisexual_female, because the sexual contact between the girls is incidental.
This does not contradict my previous point, it's merely a logical extension of the view that tags should be used when useful. When someone searches for bisexual_female. what they are looking for is the specific subset of pictures that show females being into guys and gals at the same time, and thus the use of the tag wouldn't be useful if the results are the same as that of an ffm_threesome search.

I'm tired of this conversation.

What Yuri means and how Japs use it should be respected, specially here.

Calling Yuri something that is not Yuri is not right.

Don't talk to me about non catchy tags, I made the cleft_of_venus tag work, terrible name, non catchy at all, and I still made it work. On r34.xxx they use female/female. That's not bad.

What if you guys settle in something like

If both girls are clearly lesbian use the yuri tag
otherwise if its not clear or one of them can be seen to not be into it and the other is, use the female_on_female tag

That's fine by me.

A burner account (that has previously been banned) is posting edited pics and mistagging posts as canon ships : gelbooru.com/index.php?pa...=tag_edits&id=1418440

I was under the impression that Bridget from Guilty Gear was required to be referred to as a boy for the sake of avoiding tag wars etc.

But this person seems to be consistently changing the tag and removing things like trap / cross dressing etc, and changing 1boy to 1girl, and so on.
gelbooru.com/index.php?pa...p;s=profile&id=543596

On my own art, they even removed me as the artist in the process of changing the tags, which I assume was in some way intentional.
gelbooru.com/index.php?pa...ag_history&id=9668117