LivingCorpse commented at 2019-02-22 09:36:57 » #2339746

Can I milk her?

7 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-22 12:19:48 » #2339831

No. Canonically a dyke.

2 Points Flag

Incubus_Index commented at 2019-02-22 13:45:46 » #2339853

Anon1 She isn't a dyke. She dates a guy in the story and while she's tomboyish she definitely prefers men.

15 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-22 14:15:54 » #2339861

You're actually giving me doubts now, was she not at the ranch when the other minotaurs get raped?

3 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-23 06:21:30 » #2340093

She’s currently getting milked and probably engaging in monthly lesbian orgies with horny goat girls but she specifically requested Mr. Darling himself to milk her because apparently he’s good at it. Where is the man she was originally into? Uncertain, maybe she realized she preferred being touched by monster girl tamer there, the relationship simply fizzled or they’re on a break and need time and space away from each other.

1 Points Flag

Incubus_Index commented at 2019-02-23 17:09:55 » #2340299

How did you all come to this conclusion? Anon 2 & 3 Cathyl and Merino went to the black lily ranch to get money for selling their milk. Same as most of the girls. Cathy and Merino weren't involved with the Satyrs takeover. I can't say what happened to them after Kurusu left but Cathy has a boyfriend. See chapter 33 online or Volume 8 of the manga for proof.

6 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-24 07:03:20 » #2340581

Even though there were milking machines available, she insisted on the guy. She remembers how he milked her from just that one time and didn’t even mention her boyfriend during the Farm arc. She might still be with her bf but her actually wanting to be milked by another guy just because it felt good really puts things in that gray area. I mean there was a whole dialogue in Pulp Fiction on whether or not a foot rub was considered sexual, although to be fair Tarantino definitely has a foot fetish. But this is definitely way more than a foot rub and Kimihito was clearly uncomfortable with the whole thing even though he’s not officially dating anyone.

1 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-25 22:02:46 » #2341356

All I know is my dream is a Cathyl/Tio sandwich, so canon can shove it as far as I'm concerned. :P

4 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2019-02-27 22:54:43 » #2342370

I mean regardless of the goat takeover they all wanted darling's darling not one day prior, I highly doubt they're somehow not into guys all of a sudden, even if they enjoy goat orgies now.

1 Points Flag

Incubus_Index commented at 2019-03-03 05:43:56 » #2343862

There's a profile list for all the girls from the Black Lily Ranch and it states a small bit of the girls interest and/or hobbies for anyone interested dailylifewithamonstergirl...dents_of_Black_Lily_Ranch

Anyway Cathyl's boyfriend usually milks her, but he's not there for the Black Lily arc so she asked Kurusu since he "did it" so well before. I have no intention of knocking anyone's ship, I just want the facts to be known.

6 Points Flag